More Information on Lip Balm Packaging…They’re Paper!

I wanted to talk a little bit more about the compostable lip balm tubes I’ve found from Eco Vision. I’m not sure I was very clear in my last post about it. So let me lay out the facts here so you can give me your feedback with all the information in your hands.

::These tubes are NOT “compostable” plastic. I don’t consider those products truly compostable or eco-friendly as they must be composted in a commercial composting facility – not in your worm bin or backyard compost bin. I wrote a post about this some time ago on my other blog, and EcoGrrl and EcoYogini just left comments about this on my last post. So be assured, these tubes are plastic-free and made of paper.

::These tubes have Fake Plastic Fish’s stamp of approval.

::They are made from 100% post consumer waste paper.

This lip balm is made by the wonderful company Organic Essence. This tube is the same kind I am considering for my line.

::I have been assured that they are “biodegradable” and “home compostable.” (“Biodegradable” is not necessarily a green selling point, as there are a lot of non-eco-friendly items that are “biodegradable.” That’s a loose term, as far as I’m concerned. But “home compostable” is reassuring to me.)

:The tubes hold a little more than .20 ounces of lip balm, which is about 20% more than what you will find in a plastic lip balm tube (those contain between .12 and .15 ounces of lip balm). Just for your information, the lip balms in the tins I sell contain .50 ounces of lip balm.

::They are made with an organic adhesive and glaze.

::These tubes don’t have a twist bottom that pushes the lip balm up – you squeeze it up, as you would with a toothpaste tube. However, because these are so small, you will NOT need to “roll” the bottom up as you go! :)

If I do decide to go ahead with this new packaging, I may not be able to afford the minimum order to have the tubes printed the way I want, in which case, I’ll have to use my regular labels on them. So admittedly, my tubes probably won’t be as pretty as those by Organic Essence! ;)

I’m still unsure if this is the right path for Five Seed, as part of me associates “compostable” with “disposable.” But I realized last night that I have no idea what people are doing with their lip balm tins that I currently sell once they are empty. Are people truly willing and able to reuse them? Would customers be more likely to wash and reuse their tins, or to toss paper tubes into the compost bin?

In other words, I realized that ultimately, I can’t control what happens to my packaging once it leaves my hands. In my happiest thoughts, it all goes to people who wash out the tins and find ingenuous ways to reuse them. But I don’t know that. I’m now questioning whether or not it would be “greener” to offer people the option of buying these paper tubes for those who don’t WANT to deal with washing and reusing a tin, but who would be willing to throw the tubes into the compost bin.

Anyway…now that you have all the information, I would love to hear more of your opinions on this. I created a short survey (6 questions) that you can access here. In order to show my appreciation for the time you spend answering these questions (almost all are yes or no multiple choice questions), I am offering a discount code for 10% off an order of $25 or more.* In order to receive the discount code, I need your name and email address (the first question on the survey). This information will NOT be shared or sold. I only ask for it so that I can keep track of the discount codes. You can skip this question, if you have any privacy concerns, or would like to remain anonymous, but without your first and last name and a valid email address, you will not be eligible to receive the discount code.

Thank you all for your feedback!

*The discount code will be sent to your email address within a few days of completeing the survey. It can only be used once, and is not valid with any other promotional code. You must answer at least 3 of the survey questions to receive the code. The code expires on October 1, 2010.

About these ads

38 thoughts on “More Information on Lip Balm Packaging…They’re Paper!

  1. My opinion? Go with the compostable paper if you can afford it. Metal requires mining and a lot of energy to produce, and like you said, what are people going to do with the tin when they’re done with it? I guess the only better option would be if you took the tins back to use again for more lip balm.

    But the beauty of the tube is that you will tap into a whole new customer base of people who don’t want to use a tin because they don’t want to use their fingers. Those are people that would be buying and throwing away plastic anyway.

    Like you, I usually avoid disposables too. But in this case, I think compostable is the way to go. Just my several cents.

  2. Wondering where you are ordering the tubes from…I’m interested in using them as well for my own balms and sticking my label on them instead of having them printed, but haven’t found a source. Thanks in advance! ~Briar

  3. This is a great post! I found this, as I too have been searching for an eco-friendly lip tube. I would love to know where to find them if you are willing to share.

  4. Hello! I think these tubes are great! I have seen Organic Essence carry them, as well as For Strange Women, I think the design is ingenious and a wonderful alternative. Would you mind if I asked where you’ve found these? I’ve searching for a while, coming up with no supplier. I think if more bath and beauty companies switched to these, we would have far less waste. I currently use a tin container since I want to stay plastic-free in my packaging, however, tin is not that environmentally friendly in the first place, and not as sanitary as a push balm. Best of luck to you and your company!

    • @tarawithkatie and @Kedar: I’m not at home right now and don’t know the URL offhand. Just type it into Google. A few sites come up called Eco Vision, but it’s one of the first five. Just look for the lip balm tubes.

  5. I’ve been trying for years to get these people to sell to me. They don’t answer my inquiries. Have you had any luck? I will split an order with you if you would be willing! Please let me know – I am dying for some of these tubes!


    (fellow EcoEtsy teammate!) (-:

  6. Hi! I’d love to use these for solid perfume… the Eco-Vision website that I found looks a little sketchy & there’s no ordering page.. :) Just wondering if you ever found the URL and could forward it along. I, too, wouldn’t mind getting in on a shared order!!

    Thank you,


  7. Hey there, I was wondering if you can help me.
    I’m searching & searching for a place where I can buy some wholesale eco friendly lip balm tubes, I can’t seem to find the right website..
    How do you order from eco vision? I am utterly confused :(
    thanks a bunch,

  8. The tubes are great but the corners on the lids dig into your thigh should you forget that its in
    your pocket, the lid needs to be improved. Any alternative?

    • @Damian: I don’t know of any other company that makes tubes like this (paper), but I imagine that new designs and alternatives will become available as these gain popularity. At least, I hope so! I think they are a fabulous alternative to plastic!

  9. Hi Five Seed!! Thank you so much for this helpful site and for promoting eco-friendly products! This is the future of packaging… It’s a shame more companies don’t offer or push this type of thing, in fact I’ve been looking and looking for a company that can sell me these type of paper tubes, but with no luck )-: I would be so grateful if you could point me in the right direction! Thank you again!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s